Feature/fallback pairing seed2 #5614
Merged
Conversation
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
This commit includes the following changes: I have added a flag to maintain 2.29 compatibility. Breaking change in connection string The local pairing code that was parsing the connection string had a few non-upgradable features: It was strictly checking the number of parameters, throwing an error if the number was different. This made it impossible to add parameters to it without breaking. It was strictly checking the version number. This made increasing the version number impossible as older client would just refuse to connect. The code has been changed so that: Two parameters have been added, installation-id and key-uid. Those are needed for the fallback flow. I have also removed version from the payload, since it wasn't used. This means that we don't support v1 anymore. V2 parsing is supported . Going forward there's a clear strategy on how to update the protocol (append parameters, don't change existing one). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyLBGkS5ICk Is a must watch video for understanding the strategy Changed MessengerResponse to use internally a map of installations rather than an array (minor) Just moving towards maps as arrays tend to lead to subtle bugs. Moved pairing methods to messenger_pairing.go Just moved some methods Added 2 new methods for the fallback flow FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R29 EnableAndSyncInstallation https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R18 Flow for clients Client A1 is logged in Client A2 is logged out Client A1 shows a QR code Client A2 scans a QR code If connection fails on A2, the user will be prompted to enter a seed phrase. If the generated account matches the key-uid from the QR code, A2 should call FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess with the installation id passed in the QR code. This will send installation information over waku. The user should be shown its own installation id and prompted to check the other device. Client A1 will receive new installation data through waku, if they are still on the qr code page, they should show a popup to the user showing the received installation id, and a way to Enable and Sync, which should call the EnableAndSyncInstallation endpoint. This should finish the fallback syncing flow. Current issues Currently I haven't tested that all the data is synced after finishing the flow. I see that the two devices are paired correctly, but for example the DisplayName is not changed on the receiving device. I haven't had time to look into it further.
qfrank
requested review from
igor-sirotin,
Samyoul,
ilmotta,
jrainville and
osmaczko
Jenkins BuildsClick to see older builds (33)
|
osmaczko
approved these changes
Jul 29, 2024
protocol/requests/finish_pairing_through_seed_phrase_process.go
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
igor-sirotin
approved these changes
Jul 29, 2024
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thank you for the changes ❤️
I still have 2 comments opened, please take a look if you think it make sense.
Also I think @Samyoul review is important to have here.
Also cc @jrainville about this PR.
Samyoul
reviewed
Jul 30, 2024
Samyoul
reviewed
Jul 30, 2024
ilmotta
pushed a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 30, 2024
* feat(pairing)!: Add extra parameters and remove v2 compatibility This commit includes the following changes: I have added a flag to maintain 2.29 compatibility. Breaking change in connection string The local pairing code that was parsing the connection string had a few non-upgradable features: It was strictly checking the number of parameters, throwing an error if the number was different. This made it impossible to add parameters to it without breaking. It was strictly checking the version number. This made increasing the version number impossible as older client would just refuse to connect. The code has been changed so that: Two parameters have been added, installation-id and key-uid. Those are needed for the fallback flow. I have also removed version from the payload, since it wasn't used. This means that we don't support v1 anymore. V2 parsing is supported . Going forward there's a clear strategy on how to update the protocol (append parameters, don't change existing one). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyLBGkS5ICk Is a must watch video for understanding the strategy Changed MessengerResponse to use internally a map of installations rather than an array (minor) Just moving towards maps as arrays tend to lead to subtle bugs. Moved pairing methods to messenger_pairing.go Just moved some methods Added 2 new methods for the fallback flow FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R29 EnableAndSyncInstallation https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R18 Flow for clients Client A1 is logged in Client A2 is logged out Client A1 shows a QR code Client A2 scans a QR code If connection fails on A2, the user will be prompted to enter a seed phrase. If the generated account matches the key-uid from the QR code, A2 should call FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess with the installation id passed in the QR code. This will send installation information over waku. The user should be shown its own installation id and prompted to check the other device. Client A1 will receive new installation data through waku, if they are still on the qr code page, they should show a popup to the user showing the received installation id, and a way to Enable and Sync, which should call the EnableAndSyncInstallation endpoint. This should finish the fallback syncing flow. Current issues Currently I haven't tested that all the data is synced after finishing the flow. I see that the two devices are paired correctly, but for example the DisplayName is not changed on the receiving device. I haven't had time to look into it further. * test_: add more test for connection string parser * fix_: fix panic when parse old connection string * test_: add comments for TestMessengerPairAfterSeedPhrase * fix_: correct error description * feat_:rename FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess to EnableInstallationAndPair * fix_: delete leftover * fix_: add UniqueKey method * fix_: unify the response for InputConnectionStringForBootstrapping * fix_: remove fields installationID and keyUID in GethStatusBackend * fix_: rename messenger_pairing to messenger_pairing_and_syncing --------- Co-authored-by: Andrea Maria Piana <[email protected]>
ilmotta
pushed a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 30, 2024
* feat(pairing)!: Add extra parameters and remove v2 compatibility This commit includes the following changes: I have added a flag to maintain 2.29 compatibility. Breaking change in connection string The local pairing code that was parsing the connection string had a few non-upgradable features: It was strictly checking the number of parameters, throwing an error if the number was different. This made it impossible to add parameters to it without breaking. It was strictly checking the version number. This made increasing the version number impossible as older client would just refuse to connect. The code has been changed so that: Two parameters have been added, installation-id and key-uid. Those are needed for the fallback flow. I have also removed version from the payload, since it wasn't used. This means that we don't support v1 anymore. V2 parsing is supported . Going forward there's a clear strategy on how to update the protocol (append parameters, don't change existing one). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyLBGkS5ICk Is a must watch video for understanding the strategy Changed MessengerResponse to use internally a map of installations rather than an array (minor) Just moving towards maps as arrays tend to lead to subtle bugs. Moved pairing methods to messenger_pairing.go Just moved some methods Added 2 new methods for the fallback flow FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R29 EnableAndSyncInstallation https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R18 Flow for clients Client A1 is logged in Client A2 is logged out Client A1 shows a QR code Client A2 scans a QR code If connection fails on A2, the user will be prompted to enter a seed phrase. If the generated account matches the key-uid from the QR code, A2 should call FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess with the installation id passed in the QR code. This will send installation information over waku. The user should be shown its own installation id and prompted to check the other device. Client A1 will receive new installation data through waku, if they are still on the qr code page, they should show a popup to the user showing the received installation id, and a way to Enable and Sync, which should call the EnableAndSyncInstallation endpoint. This should finish the fallback syncing flow. Current issues Currently I haven't tested that all the data is synced after finishing the flow. I see that the two devices are paired correctly, but for example the DisplayName is not changed on the receiving device. I haven't had time to look into it further. * test_: add more test for connection string parser * fix_: fix panic when parse old connection string * test_: add comments for TestMessengerPairAfterSeedPhrase * fix_: correct error description * feat_:rename FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess to EnableInstallationAndPair * fix_: delete leftover * fix_: add UniqueKey method * fix_: unify the response for InputConnectionStringForBootstrapping * fix_: remove fields installationID and keyUID in GethStatusBackend * fix_: rename messenger_pairing to messenger_pairing_and_syncing --------- Co-authored-by: Andrea Maria Piana <[email protected]>
|
@qfrank |
oh sure, sorry, generally I will create a mobile PR to test, but the time is urgent and I forget to do this for the first time(I tested it several times with different client version on my side before merging) @churik |
ilmotta
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 30, 2024
* feat(pairing)!: Add extra parameters and remove v2 compatibility This commit includes the following changes: I have added a flag to maintain 2.29 compatibility. Breaking change in connection string The local pairing code that was parsing the connection string had a few non-upgradable features: It was strictly checking the number of parameters, throwing an error if the number was different. This made it impossible to add parameters to it without breaking. It was strictly checking the version number. This made increasing the version number impossible as older client would just refuse to connect. The code has been changed so that: Two parameters have been added, installation-id and key-uid. Those are needed for the fallback flow. I have also removed version from the payload, since it wasn't used. This means that we don't support v1 anymore. V2 parsing is supported . Going forward there's a clear strategy on how to update the protocol (append parameters, don't change existing one). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyLBGkS5ICk Is a must watch video for understanding the strategy Changed MessengerResponse to use internally a map of installations rather than an array (minor) Just moving towards maps as arrays tend to lead to subtle bugs. Moved pairing methods to messenger_pairing.go Just moved some methods Added 2 new methods for the fallback flow FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R29 EnableAndSyncInstallation https://github.com/status-im/status-go/pull/5567/files#diff-1ad620b07fa3bd5fbc96c9f459d88829938a162bf1aaf41c61dea6e38b488d54R18 Flow for clients Client A1 is logged in Client A2 is logged out Client A1 shows a QR code Client A2 scans a QR code If connection fails on A2, the user will be prompted to enter a seed phrase. If the generated account matches the key-uid from the QR code, A2 should call FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess with the installation id passed in the QR code. This will send installation information over waku. The user should be shown its own installation id and prompted to check the other device. Client A1 will receive new installation data through waku, if they are still on the qr code page, they should show a popup to the user showing the received installation id, and a way to Enable and Sync, which should call the EnableAndSyncInstallation endpoint. This should finish the fallback syncing flow. Current issues Currently I haven't tested that all the data is synced after finishing the flow. I see that the two devices are paired correctly, but for example the DisplayName is not changed on the receiving device. I haven't had time to look into it further. * test_: add more test for connection string parser * fix_: fix panic when parse old connection string * test_: add comments for TestMessengerPairAfterSeedPhrase * fix_: correct error description * feat_:rename FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess to EnableInstallationAndPair * fix_: delete leftover * fix_: add UniqueKey method * fix_: unify the response for InputConnectionStringForBootstrapping * fix_: remove fields installationID and keyUID in GethStatusBackend * fix_: rename messenger_pairing to messenger_pairing_and_syncing --------- Co-authored-by: frank <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Andrea Maria Piana <[email protected]>
ilmotta
pushed a commit
to status-im/status-mobile
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 30, 2024
Creating this PR for regression testing the comparability of feature sync between different versions(mainly current PR build vs v2.29) after adding backend fallback pairing support. Because frontend haven't added the invocations relate to fallback pairing API yet, so fallback pairing won't support with current build. relate status-go PR status-im/status-go#5614 Testing notes expected: sync should work as before between different versions like following: v2.29 <-> PR build PR build <-> recent desktop build NOTE: It breaks with v1 of pairing, but that's ancient (last year I believe), so safe to break.
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
this is a continue PR to PR.
with this PR, syncing will work with both direction: v2.29 <-> v2.30
also will work between v2.30 <-> v2.31
once frontend added the 2 invocations
FinishPairingThroughSeedPhraseProcess,EnableAndSyncInstallationand backend disabled the flagkeep229Compatibility, fall back should work between v2.31 -> v2.30 or v2.31 <-> v2.31@cammellos @ilmotta